Was Dave Barry ever funny?
Today’s avalanche of books brings the new (on sale August 5) Dave Barry book. This took me aback, because I had forgotten all about Dave Barry, rather like the grody beer-swilling uncle you once thought was so cool. Then you grew up, and he didn’t. That’s what Dave Barry seems like these days: the annoyance on the bookstore shelf.
Dave Barry’s History of the Millennium (So Far) (Berkley Trade Paperback Reprint, $14) features a cover design that illustrates perfectly what I mean: Barry is Photoshopped flashing rabbit ears over the head of President George W. Bush. I’m sure there’s a preschool somewhere where that’s still cutting-edge humor.
And then there’s Barry’s style, which has always relied on juxtaposing the mundane with the absurd and then tossing in some random reference to something that’s adolescent and probably booger-related and hoping against hope that You Get It.
But let’s do this by example, in this entry from June, 2003: “On the literary front, the blockbuster bestseller of the year is the long-awaited fifth Harry Potter book, Harry Potter Reaches Puberty and Starts Taking Really Long Showers. Another best-seller is Sen. Hillary Clinton’s new book, I Can’t Help It If I’m a Saint, in which, with great candor and openness, her ghostwriter reveals the most intimate details of Sen. Clinton’s life, except the parts that might be interesting, which fall within Sen. Clinton’s “Zone of Privacy.”‘
The problems here are about as infinite as Barry’s fascination with lame puberty jokes:
–This is really lazy writing.
–You suspect that Jon Stewart and “The Daily Show” could have made short work out of both events. (Or Joel McHale, or The Onion, or the Websites 236.com or Wonkette. Good Lord, there’s more sophisticated, harder-working humor on icanhascheezburger.com)
–And the Daily Show is on basic cable, and the InterWebs are basically free, whereas Barry is expecting you to shell out $14 for a collection of his end-of-year columns, slightly updated. And while $14 for a belly laugh is no bad deal, this book is just a Dave Barry literary garage sale, and jokes about Martha Stewart and Paris Hilton and Dan Rather really have reached their “sell-by” date.
–And even in a literary garage sale — basically, a writer dumping everything he didn’t get published in the big leagues between two covers and calling it an anthology, or “the collected,” or “the uncollected,” or “stuff no magazine, print or online, would sneeze on these days” — there is occasionally a pink flamingo, an item that’s fun and kitschy and makes you proud to haul it off to the car and pose it in front of your coffee table.
Dave Barry may make a comeback, like Abba or “The Golden Girls.”
But this is no pink flamingo.
.
Cheryl Truman, a Kentucky native, reads to excess, owns too many pets and is occasionally successful in her crusade to get her children to read Erik Larson and Mary Doria Russell. She occupies herself wondering when Chuck Palahniuk is going to write a children's book. Her favorite book, at least for now, is Wallace Stegner's Angle of Repose. Truman is seeking a doorstop book to carry her through the summer season -- something like Pillars of the Earth or An Instance of the Fingerpost: juicy, historical and including absolutely no abdominal-flattening exercises. Your nominations are welcome.